KID GALAHAD has a lot going for it - a great cast, solid direction,
plenty of action - but it still fails to be anything but an average
Warner Brothers potboiler. Edward G. Robinson, as a smalltime
boxing promoter, doesn't do anything special with the part
except be Edward G. Robinson, meaning you get his usual megaton of
energy
in nearly every scene, but you can almost sense him and Humphrey Bogart
setting themselves on
autopilot. Despite being third billed (below Bertte Davis),
Bogie has
almost nothing to do except look menacing and spout gangster cliches
while snearing. Being Bogart, he's very good at this, but it is
still one of his least rewarding parts. It's up to Bette Davis to
make something out of nothing, playing Robinson's girl who falls in
love with his new and inexperienced boxer, Ward Guiesenberry, aka "Kid
Galahad". It's not a terribly rewarding part for her either, but
she gives it her all and manages a winning, winsome performance..
As with so many Warner Brothers pictures from
this period, it's entertaining, but no classic. It's so average,
the 1940 remake THE WAGONS ROLL AT NIGHT, starring Humphrey Bogart as a
circus owner promoting a new and inexperienced lion tamer(!) is
actually superior on several points.
- JB